For detailed feedback on individual pages download
your coursework file by clicking on a link from below. Open
up your file and read the comments that have been insirted
in comment boxes on each page.
Coursework you submited @ 26/09/07
| Page |
Completed |
Feedback |
Breakdown
|
Date |
Project
outline
Deadline 26/09/07
|
@ 26/09/07yes |
@
26/09/07 |
Clearly
explains the context to witch your product will be introduced
within. |
@
26/09/07yes |
| Explains
why your doing what you are |
@
26/09/07yes |
Introduction
and brief
Deadline
26/09/07 |
@
26/09/07no |
@
26/09/07 very good. could do with going into
just a little more detail |
Says
who the target market is / who will use it |
@
26/09/07yes |
| Explains
the problem to be solved by your product |
@
26/09/07yes |
| Explains
what your product will need to do |
@
26/09/07nearly |
| Explains
the need for your product |
@
26/09/07yes |
| |
|
Task
Analysis
Deadline 26/09/07
|
@
26/09/07no |
@
26/09/07 very good points made. needs organising
into categories and more. needs a more comments as well |
Breaks
the task up into many questions that will need answers |
@
26/09/07yes |
| Is
clearly and logically laid out |
@
26/09/07nearly |
| Has
a good range of statements that relate to all areas of
your design |
@
26/09/07nearly |
| Breaks
up the task by circuit and by case |
@
26/09/07no |
| |
|
Research
3 Pages
Deadline 26/09/07 |
@
26/09/07no |
@
26/09/07
Product analysis needs more depth.
you have no research on components!
you must look closely at this page and read all the
things that must be shown within your research.
|
Research
on individual components that you could use |
@
26/09/07no |
| Shows
pin outs of your components |
@
26/09/07no |
| Shows
price of components |
@
26/09/07no |
| Shows
size of components |
@
26/09/07no |
| Shows
technical information about component like how much power
it needs to run, how much power it can handle before it
burns out, what its frequency bandwidth is (for 741 as
amps) etc |
@
26/09/07no |
| Research
on 3 different circuits that would do the job you require
|
@
26/09/07no |
| Each
gathered circuit uses different components or the same
components but used if a different way |
@
26/09/07no |
| Has
comments about how useful each circuit or components would
be for your circuit |
@
26/09/07no |
| Has
comments that prove you understand how the circuit or
components works |
@
26/09/07no |
| Research
on materials for case showing there working properties |
@
26/09/07no |
| Research
on materials for case showing ways of joining them |
@
26/09/07no |
| Research
on materials showing ways of shaping and manipulating
them |
@
26/09/07no |
| 3
existing products that do a similar thing to yours |
@
26/09/07yes |
| Comments
about the existing products, like what is good or bad
about them and how looking at them has given you ideas
and what these ideas are… |
@
26/09/07nearly |
| Market
research where you find out what the customer wants |
@
26/09/07yes |
| Market
research has at least 6 questions that will help you to
understand what the customer wants. Questions must be
useful to you! |
@
26/09/07yes |
| Research
on environmental impact of the components and materials
you are using (this can be shown in the materials or components
pages or within your ‘Issues’ Page –
env, social etc) |
@
26/09/07no |
| Your
research is not just from the internet and is from a wide
range of sources |
@
26/09/07no |
| Research
on industrial practices showing that you know how its
all done in industry (this can be shown within your Industrial
practice page) |
@
26/09/07no |
| |
|
Research
Summery
Deadline 26/09/07
|
@
26/09/07no |
@
26/09/07 |
All
comments relate to the research that you have in your
coursework |
@
26/09/07no |
| Your
comments on this page are arranged into categories, like
case, circuit, materials, components etc |
@
26/09/07no |
| You
have shown that you have made decisions based on what
you have found out within your research |
@
26/09/07nearly |
| You
have shown that you can select the useful parts of your
gathered research and use them to progress your designs |
@
26/09/07no |
| |
|
Specification
Deadline 26/09/07
Deadline day
click
here to see work submited on 26-09-07
Comment: still
needs work. read through comments on attached to the
file you can download at top of page.. |
@
26/09/07no |
@
26/09/07 really good clear and logical start.
need more details adding and more categories. |
Your
specification is laid out logically (has headings like,
aesthetic, ergonomics, function, safety, target market,
materials, then a bit about what your product will do
next to it… |
@
26/09/07yes |
| Explains
what the Function must be |
@
26/09/07nearly |
| Explains
what the Target Market must be |
@
26/09/07yes |
| Explains
what the Size must be |
@
26/09/07no |
| Explains
what the Weight must be |
@
26/09/07no |
| Explains
what the Maintenance must be |
@
26/09/07yes |
| Explains
what the Aesthetic must be |
@
26/09/07yes |
| Explains
what the Safety must be |
@
26/09/07yes |
| Explains
what the Time/Deadline must be |
@
26/09/07yes |
| Explains
what the Environmental issues must be |
@
26/09/07no |
| Explains
what the Manufacturing must be (what scale of production?) |
@
26/09/07no |
| Explains
what the Cost must be |
@
26/09/07yes |
| Explains
what the Power Supply must be |
@
26/09/07yes |
| Explains
what the Assembly must be |
@
26/09/07no |
| Explains
what the Parameters must be (what are the working parameters
of my electronic components) |
@
26/09/07no |
| |
|
3
Circuit Designs
Deadline 00/00/00
|
no |
|
You
have tried three different ways of achieving the same
goal (each of the three circuits you have designed/modified
does more or less the same thing) |
|
| You
have made comments here about what each circuit is doing |
|
| You
have identified the good and bad aspects of each circuit |
|
| Through
your comments you have shown you understand what |
|
Circuit
development
Deadline 00/00/00
|
no |
|
You
have selected one of your three circuits that best meets
your requirements |
|
| You
have simulated your circuit using croc clips or live wire
and it works |
|
| You
have prototyped your circuit by breadboarding it and it
works |
|
| You
have documented all procedures with pictures and appropriate
comments that show you are understanding what you are
doing and correcting any errors within your circuit as
you go. |
|
| You
have transferred any modifications you made when breadboarding
back onto your circuit diagram on croc clips or live wire. |
|
| |
|
Breadboarding
Deadline 00/00/00 |
no |
|
Within
your breadboarding you have worked logically and neatly |
|
| You
have come across problems when breadboarding your circuit
and resolved them and documented what you did in a clear
and concise way |
|
| You
have justified any need for changes made within this part
of your circuit development |
|
| |
|
3
Case ideas
Deadline 00/00/00
|
no |
|
You
have at least 3 ideas for your case that show a good level
of detail (where switches, buzzers, LEDs etc go, what
materials it could be made of, what colour/texture it
could be, a rough idea of the size etc etc) |
|
| You
have annotated your initial drawings to give extra details
of you casing |
|
| All
design drawings are on bordered pages with candidate details
and headings |
|
| You
have used colour, thickness of line and tone to help increase
your clearness of visual communication. |
|
Case
Development
Deadline 00/00/00
|
no |
|
You
have chosen the best one of your designs and justified
the reasons for your choice |
|
| You
have communicated the measurements of your product |
|
| You
have visually communicated how all parts of your product
will fit together |
|
| You
have devised a way to secure all your components including
your battery and circuit |
|
Prototype
Deadline 00/00/00 |
no |
|
You
have made a 3D model of your case to fully realise it
before you go ahead with making it for real. |
|
| You
model is neat and accurate to your design drawings |
|
| You
have documented it with pictures and comments on what
you have discovered and needed to change as a result of
making it. |
|
| |
|
PCB
design
Deadline 00/00/00
|
no |
|
You
have created a PCB layout that matches your working circuit
diagram |
|
| Your
PCB layout is laid out a space efficient way so as to
keep the size of the circuit down whilst still having
enough space around components to easily work on them
when soldering then in |
|
| You
have created a transparency or your PCB layout to be used
to print your PCB (picture needed or transparency) |
|
| you
have considered the size of your circuit in relation to
it fitting within your case and commented on this. |
|
Making
in Industry
Deadline 00/00/00
|
no |
|
You
have shown that you understand how your product would
be made in industry |
|
| You
have explained pick and place |
|
| You
have explained levels of production and which would best
suit your product |
|
| You
have explained how PCBs are made within industry |
|
| You
have explained any industrial procedures and how they
work relating to how your product is made ( eg. If you
vacuum formed your mould then how do they do it in industry
or if you have used metal then how do they use it in industry….) |
|
| You
have showed that you understand Quality control, inspection,
codes of working in relation to your own work as well
as within what happens in industry |
|
Environmental
/ Social issues
Deadline 00/00/00
|
no |
|
|
|
| |
|
| |
|
| |
|
| |
|
Flowchart
Deadline 00/00/00
|
no |
|
|
|
| |
|
| |
|
| |
|
| |
|
Hot
to make
Deadline 00/00/00
|
no |
|
|
|
| |
|
| |
|
| |
|
| |
|
Testing
and QA
Deadline 00/00/00
|
no |
|
|
|
| |
|
| |
|
| |
|
| |
|
Evaluation
3 Pages
Deadline 00/00/00 |
no |
|
|
|
| |
|
| |
|
| |
|
| |
|
| |
